Edition: July 2004



 Real Property

 By Alan N. Nevin
PropertyMaps: MLS Real Estate Search


« Previous Month | Next Month »

Jobs R Us
San Diego’s strong economy
portends a day of housing reckoning

This column almost always focuses exclusively on real estate. But this time you get a break from that tedium. Instead, we’ll talk about something really exciting: jobs. We have them and we’re getting more.

Let’s start out with a snapshot of San Diego County’s economy. We have 1,447,700 civilian jobs in addition to a bit more than 120,000 persons in uniform. Since 2000 we have gained 103,300 civilian jobs, fully one-fifth of all the jobs gained in the nation.

Our unemployment rate is 3.8 percent compared to 5.8 percent in California and 5.6 percent nationwide. It is not quite as low as the 2.9 percent that we had in 2001, but it still is something to crow about.

To what do we owe our good fortune? The answer is a combination of many basic industries gaining strength and no one basic industry falling on hard times as has happened in the past. (A basic industry is one that derives most of its revenues from outside its metropolitan area. In San Diego, that’s the military, tourism, manufacturing, high-tech/biotech/telecom, the university system, import/export and much of the business services employment.)

Most folks immediately focus on manufacturing as the bellwether of our economy. Our manufacturing base accounts for fewer than 8 percent of our wage and salary jobs. Yes, we have lost 18,300 or 14.8 percent of those manufacturing jobs since the beginning of our downturn, but I must point out that our track record is much better than those of either California or the nation. The United States as a whole lost 20 percent of its manufacturing jobs and California 16.7 percent. Our comparatively light loss is due to the diversity of our manufacturing base.

We have numerous sub-areas of manufacturing, including electrical equipment, machinery, computer peripherals and telecommunications equipment. A major portion of the manufacturing is sophisticated and high-tech.

The other two industries that make up our “big three” in terms of basic jobs are tourism and the military. Tourism is on a roll. Employment is up 11.4 percent since 2000, a period that includes riding out the dramatic post Sept. 11 travel slowdown. In the past year, visitor spending is up 6 percent, airport arrivals up 8.6 percent and hotel occupancy is up 5 percent. Our occupancy rate of 72.4 percent is the third highest in the nation (Las Vegas is always No. 1). This summer should be a bonanza, thanks to the Midway, the new thrill ride at SeaWorld, Petco Park, additional cruise ships and the overall recovery of the economy.

The military is chugging right along. It may be insensitive to say this, but war has always been good for San Diego. Our county is No. 1 in Department of Defense payroll, with $4.3 billion annually, half of total expenditures in California. In terms of procurement contracts, we rank No. 3 in the nation, lagging only behind Los Angeles and Fairfax County, Va.

Other industries that have a positive bent are our university system — with major expansion and construction underway at UCSD, despite what you hear about tight budgets — and import/export and financial services.

JOB CATEGORY MAY 2000 MAY 2004 CHANGE % CHANGE
WINNERS
CONSTRUCTION 68,200 87,200 9,000 27.9%
LEISURE & HOSPITALITY 129,600 144,100 14,500 11.2%
RETAILING 131,100 139,900 8,800 6.7%
FINANCIAL SERVICES 71,100 83,200 12,100 17.0%
PROFESSIONAL & BUSINESS SERVICES 191,900 201,300 9,400 4.9%
EDUCATIONAL & HEALTH SERVICES 115,600 125,400 9,800 8.5%
LOSERS
MANUFACTURING 123,400 105,100 -18,300 -14.8%
INFORMATION/TELECOM 40,300 36,300 -4,000 -9.9%
GOVERNMENT 213,500 221,600 8,100 3.8%
Source: California EDD and Market Pointe Realty Advisors 6.04

Where’s the weak point? Let me venture to say that our manufacturing decline has leveled off as has the decline in telecommunications. There appears to be no other industry in the county that has been in a declining mode.

The truly big winner in the job market is construction, up 27.9 percent in the past four years. A strong job gain of 19,000. And that, of course, leads me back to real estate (it was inevitable).

In most of our past economic recoveries we have gained more than 50,000 jobs annually. Currently, we’re only moving forward at half that pace. Yet, in those past four years, despite a weak economy, our home demand has outstripped any period in the past half century and our home prices have accelerated to obscene values.

The question inevitably arises: What would happen in our county if employment began to accelerate as it has after every other recession? What if we once again produce 50,000 new jobs a year? There’s no doubt that we cannot produce more homes than we do now (we just can’t produce the lots) and the ones we have are all occupied. In other words, our standing inventory of homes is negligible.

Is it possible, therefore, that the absurdity of the prices now extant might just be a preview of what could happen if new jobs accelerate and more folks from other metropolitan areas pile in as they have in every other recovery?

Is this the time to buy that little home in El Centro that you’ve always wanted? Or maybe sell out? Move to Vegas or Phoenix (Summer’s the perfect time to move there.)? Pocket the difference. Live big again.

I feel like the mad scientist who has engineered a massive train wreck. Two trains on the same rail heading toward each other at full speed. In this case, thousands of home-seekers heading toward the same limited supply of housing. Something has to give.

Stay tuned.

Alan N. Nevin is director of economic research with MarketPointe Realty Advisors (marketpointe.com), a consultancy providing real estate and demographic statistics, feasibility studies and litigation support to the California land use industry and legal professions. Nevin can be reached by e-mail at anevin@sandiegometro.com.


Story Comments

No comments on record for this story.

Post feedback on this story
This is a public form for the free exchange of comments. Foul language, threats and anything overtly mean or nasty will be removed.
Name (required)
Email (will NOT be displayed)
Email me whenever this thread is updated.
Message (required)